Compared with doing it yourself
Nobody knows your business better, and it costs nothing but time. Time is the problem: the tests you meant to start and the budget you meant to move wait until you have a free hour.
What it does well
Doing it yourself has real advantages: you know your customers, margins and stock, there’s no one to brief or pay, and you can change course fast. But the work that compounds is daily checking, testing and moving money, and spare moments rarely come daily.
- You know the customers, the margins and the stock.
- No one to brief and no one to pay.
- You can change course the moment you decide to.
Where it stops
- 1It happens when there’s time, which is rarely every day.
- 2Knowing whether a test worked takes statistics and patience.
- 3Your limits hold only as long as you remember to check them.
- 4The reasoning lives in your head.
Side by side, with cost and time.
| Question | Doing it yourself | Heraldic |
|---|---|---|
| Stops at your limits | When you’re watching | Checked by software before every change, and again on approval |
| Explains itself | Your memory | A record of every action, with its reason |
| Who sets the limits | You, when you remember | You, and the software holds them |
| What it optimizes | Whatever you have time to check | Your conversion events, each valued by what it’s worth to you |
| Across channels | One tab at a time | One set of rules, one contact policy, one record |
| Video and large-scale creative | Whatever you can make | Still images from your approved library; video you upload sits beside them |
| Holds your credentials | You do | Agents never do. Only the executor, the part that makes changes, holds them |
| What it costs | Your time, every day it gets done. | Not set yet. Ad spend goes straight to the ad platforms |
| Time to a first result | As soon as you start, and as often as you find the time. | Set by your funnel: at a store with daily orders, a test can be called in two weeks; a lead-generation funnel takes longer. |
When to choose it instead
If your spend is small enough that there’s little to learn from it. Agents need enough volume to judge results, and their reports say when there isn’t enough.
Using both
You stay in charge: your briefs, your limits, your approvals. Agents do the checking you don’t have time for, and you can still work in your own accounts.
Questions about this comparison
How much of my time will it take?
Reading reports and deciding what’s in your inbox. Stricter permission levels mean more to decide; looser ones mean more to read.
What if my spend is small?
Agents need enough volume to judge results. With little volume, they act less often, steer by earlier steps in your funnel, and say “too early to call” instead of guessing.
Can I still change things myself?
Yes. Your accounts stay yours. Tell the agent what you changed, in a sentence, and its next plan takes it into account.
Other comparisons
- Shopify Campaign AutopilotShopify’s free AI for ads and email, built into the store admin.Costs: free; you pay for ads and sends
- Klaviyo ComposerKlaviyo’s marketing agent: drafts and audits email and SMS.Costs: priced by usage
- HubSpot’s marketing agentsHubSpot’s agents plan and draft campaigns inside your CRM.Costs: Marketing Hub Pro or Enterprise, plus credits
- MadgicxAn AI media buyer for Meta ads, built for e-commerce.Costs: from $45 a month
- The ad platforms’ AIThe ad platforms’ own AI campaigns: strong inside their own platform.Costs: no fee beyond ad spend
- An agency or freelancerExperienced people, on a retainer and a regular call.Costs: a retainer, a share of spend, or hours
- A chatbot on your accountsA general AI assistant connected to your ad accounts.Costs: a subscription, plus your time
Stop being the only one who checks.
Join the beta, or try the demo first.